| 14 Oct 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 3 - 2 | Iowa HeartlandersIowa Heartlan |
| 15 Oct 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 5 - 3 | Iowa HeartlandersIowa Heartlan |
| 20 Oct 23 | r00        | Indy FuelIndy Fuel | 1 - 4 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 21 Oct 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 1 - 3 | Indy FuelIndy Fuel |
| 28 Oct 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 2 - 9 | Toledo WalleyeToledo Walley |
| 28 Oct 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 7 - 3 | Wheeling NailersWheeling Nail |
| 04 Nov 23 | r00        | Kalamazoo WingsKalamazoo Win | 2 - 3 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 11 Nov 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 4 - 6 | Toledo WalleyeToledo Walley |
| 12 Nov 23 | r00        | Toledo WalleyeToledo Walley | 7 - 4 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 12 Nov 23 | r00        | Toledo WalleyeToledo Walley | 5 - 6 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 14 Nov 23 | r00        | Cincinnati CyclonesCincinnati Cy | 4 - 5 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 19 Nov 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 2 - 3 | Toledo WalleyeToledo Walley |
| 19 Nov 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 3 - 1 | Wheeling NailersWheeling Nail |
| 24 Nov 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 4 - 3 | Iowa HeartlandersIowa Heartlan |
| 25 Nov 23 | r00        | Indy FuelIndy Fuel | 2 - 3 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 26 Nov 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 4 - 6 | Toledo WalleyeToledo Walley |
| 02 Dec 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 1 - 3 | Indy FuelIndy Fuel |
| 03 Dec 23 | r00        | Cincinnati CyclonesCincinnati Cy | 4 - 1 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 03 Dec 23 | r00        | Indy FuelIndy Fuel | 3 - 2 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 09 Dec 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 4 - 2 | Tulsa OilersTulsa Oilers |
| 10 Dec 23 | r00        | Indy FuelIndy Fuel | 3 - 1 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 10 Dec 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 1 - 2 | Iowa HeartlandersIowa Heartlan |
| 16 Dec 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 5 - 2 | Utah GrizzliesUtah Grizzlie |
| 17 Dec 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 3 - 2 | Utah GrizzliesUtah Grizzlie |
| 17 Dec 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 6 - 3 | Utah GrizzliesUtah Grizzlie |
| 22 Dec 23 | r00        | Iowa HeartlandersIowa Heartlan | 4 - 2 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 23 Dec 23 | r00        | Iowa HeartlandersIowa Heartlan | 2 - 6 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 24 Dec 23 | r00        | Iowa HeartlandersIowa Heartlan | 1 - 4 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 28 Dec 23 | r00        | Kalamazoo WingsKalamazoo Win | 2 - 4 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 30 Dec 23 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 2 - 5 | Norfolk AdmiralsNorfolk Admir |
| 31 Dec 23 | r00        | Indy FuelIndy Fuel | 5 - 2 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 01 Jan 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 4 - 6 | Toledo WalleyeToledo Walley |
| 04 Jan 24 | r00        | Kalamazoo WingsKalamazoo Win | 0 - 1 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 06 Jan 24 | r00        | Toledo WalleyeToledo Walley | 4 - 0 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 07 Jan 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 4 - 1 | Iowa HeartlandersIowa Heartlan |
| 07 Jan 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 2 - 3 | Iowa HeartlandersIowa Heartlan |
| 11 Jan 24 | r00        | Rapid City RushRapid City Ru | 4 - 1 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 13 Jan 24 | r00        | Rapid City RushRapid City Ru | 1 - 3 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 14 Jan 24 | r00        | Rapid City RushRapid City Ru | 9 - 5 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 20 Jan 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 4 - 0 | Worcester RailersWorcester Rai |
| 21 Jan 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 3 - 4 | Worcester RailersWorcester Rai |
| 21 Jan 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 5 - 3 | Worcester RailersWorcester Rai |
| 27 Jan 24 | r00        | Kalamazoo WingsKalamazoo Win | 2 - 5 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 28 Jan 24 | r00        | Cincinnati CyclonesCincinnati Cy | 0 - 2 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 03 Feb 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 1 - 2 | Cincinnati CyclonesCincinnati Cy |
| 04 Feb 24 | r00        | Cincinnati CyclonesCincinnati Cy | 1 - 7 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 04 Feb 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 2 - 4 | Kalamazoo WingsKalamazoo Win |
| 08 Feb 24 | r00        | Kansas City MavericksKansas City M | 3 - 2 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 09 Feb 24 | r00        | Wichita ThunderWichita Thund | 3 - 4 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 11 Feb 24 | r00        | Wichita ThunderWichita Thund | 3 - 2 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 17 Feb 24 | r00        | Kalamazoo WingsKalamazoo Win | 4 - 3 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 18 Feb 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 3 - 4 | Cincinnati CyclonesCincinnati Cy |
| 18 Feb 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 1 - 4 | Cincinnati CyclonesCincinnati Cy |
| 24 Feb 24 | r00        | Wheeling NailersWheeling Nail | 3 - 5 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 25 Feb 24 | r00        | Toledo WalleyeToledo Walley | 2 - 3 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 02 Mar 24 | r00        | Toledo WalleyeToledo Walley | 6 - 3 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 03 Mar 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 7 - 4 | Wheeling NailersWheeling Nail |
| 03 Mar 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 3 - 2 | Indy FuelIndy Fuel |
| 09 Mar 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 1 - 0 | Wheeling NailersWheeling Nail |
| 10 Mar 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 3 - 4 | Wheeling NailersWheeling Nail |
| 10 Mar 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 4 - 3 | Indy FuelIndy Fuel |
| 15 Mar 24 | r00        | Cincinnati CyclonesCincinnati Cy | 3 - 6 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 16 Mar 24 | r00        | Cincinnati CyclonesCincinnati Cy | 3 - 1 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 20 Mar 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 4 - 3 | Kalamazoo WingsKalamazoo Win |
| 22 Mar 24 | r00        | Toledo WalleyeToledo Walley | 3 - 1 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 23 Mar 24 | r00        | Wheeling NailersWheeling Nail | 3 - 1 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 30 Mar 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 3 - 4 | Indy FuelIndy Fuel |
| 30 Mar 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 5 - 2 | Kalamazoo WingsKalamazoo Win |
| 06 Apr 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 2 - 1 | Indy FuelIndy Fuel |
| 07 Apr 24 | r00        | Kalamazoo WingsKalamazoo Win | 2 - 4 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 10 Apr 24 | r00        | Wheeling NailersWheeling Nail | 4 - 1 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 13 Apr 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 3 - 4 | Indy FuelIndy Fuel |
| 13 Apr 24 | r00        | Toledo WalleyeToledo Walley | 3 - 1 | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko |
| 14 Apr 24 | r00        | Fort Wayne KometsFort Wayne Ko | 3 - 4 | Toledo WalleyeToledo Walley |