| 17 Aug 85 | r00        | StokeStoke | 1 - 3 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 24 Aug 85 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 4 - 0 | AFC WimbledonAFC Wimbledon |
| 27 Aug 85 | r00        | BrightonBrighton | 0 - 0 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 31 Aug 85 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 1 - 1 | ShrewsburyShrewsbury |
| 07 Sep 85 | r00        | NorwichNorwich | 4 - 0 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 14 Sep 85 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 1 - 1 | Huddersfield TownHuddersfield |
| 17 Sep 85 | r00        | FulhamFulham | 2 - 3 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 21 Sep 85 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 0 - 1 | MiddlesbroughMiddlesbrough |
| 28 Sep 85 | r00        | LeedsLeeds | 1 - 1 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 01 Oct 85 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 1 - 1 | CharltonCharlton |
| 05 Oct 85 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 1 - 3 | MillwallMillwall |
| 12 Oct 85 | r00        | GrimsbyGrimsby | 0 - 1 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 19 Oct 85 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 3 - 1 | BarnsleyBarnsley |
| 26 Oct 85 | r00        | BradfordBradford | 1 - 4 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 02 Nov 85 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 3 - 1 | HullHull |
| 09 Nov 85 | r00        | OldhamOldham | 1 - 5 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 16 Nov 85 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 3 - 3 | BlackburnBlackburn |
| 23 Nov 85 | r00        | PortsmouthPortsmouth | 0 - 3 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 30 Nov 85 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 0 - 0 | Crystal PalaceCrystal Palac |
| 07 Dec 85 | r00        | CharltonCharlton | 2 - 0 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 14 Dec 85 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 1 - 2 | StokeStoke |
| 21 Dec 85 | r00        | AFC WimbledonAFC Wimbledon | 5 - 0 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 26 Dec 85 | r00        | SunderlandSunderland | 2 - 1 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 28 Dec 85 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 2 - 1 | FulhamFulham |
| 01 Jan 86 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 1 - 0 | CarlisleCarlisle |
| 11 Jan 86 | r00        | Huddersfield TownHuddersfield | 3 - 1 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 18 Jan 86 | r00        | ShrewsburyShrewsbury | 3 - 1 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 01 Feb 86 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 3 - 0 | BrightonBrighton |
| 08 Mar 86 | r00        | MillwallMillwall | 3 - 0 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 11 Mar 86 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 3 - 1 | BradfordBradford |
| 15 Mar 86 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 1 - 1 | GrimsbyGrimsby |
| 18 Mar 86 | r00        | MiddlesbroughMiddlesbrough | 1 - 2 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 22 Mar 86 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 2 - 5 | NorwichNorwich |
| 29 Mar 86 | r00        | CarlisleCarlisle | 1 - 0 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 31 Mar 86 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 1 - 0 | SunderlandSunderland |
| 05 Apr 86 | r00        | HullHull | 0 - 0 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 08 Apr 86 | r00        | BarnsleyBarnsley | 2 - 1 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 12 Apr 86 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 2 - 0 | OldhamOldham |
| 19 Apr 86 | r00        | BlackburnBlackburn | 6 - 1 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |
| 22 Apr 86 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 3 - 2 | LeedsLeeds |
| 26 Apr 86 | r00        | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni | 0 - 0 | PortsmouthPortsmouth |
| 03 May 86 | r00        | Crystal PalaceCrystal Palac | 1 - 1 | Sheffield UnitedSheffield Uni |