2024-2025 Aldershot Town

2023-2024 Gateshead

2022-2023 Halifax Town

2021-2022 Bromley

2020-2021 Hornchurch

2019-2020 Harrogate Town

2018-2019 AFC Fylde

2017-2018 Brackley Town

2016-2017 York City

2015-2016 Halifax Town

2013-2014 Cambridge United

2012-2013 Wrexham

2011-2012 York City

2010-2011 Darlington

2009-2010 Barrow

2008-2009 Stevenage

2007-2008 Ebbsfleet United

2006-2007 Stevenage

2005-2006 Grays

2004-2005 Grays

2003-2004 Hednesford Town

2002-2003 Burscough

2001-2002 Yeovil Town

2000-2001 Canvey Island

1999-2000 Kingstonian

1998-1999 Kingstonian

1997-1998 Cheltenham Town

1996-1997 Woking

1995-1996 Macclesfield Town

1994-1995 Woking

1993-1994 Woking

1992-1993 Wycombe Wanderers

1991-1992 Colchester United

1990-1991 Wycombe Wanderers

1989-1990 Barrow

1987-1988 Enfield

1986-1987 Kidderminster Harriers

1985-1986 Altrincham

1984-1985 Wealdstone

1983-1984 Northwich Victoria

1981-1982 Enfield

1980-1981 Bishops Stortford

1977-1978 Altrincham

1976-1977 Scarborough FC

1975-1976 Scarborough FC

1974-1975 Matlock Town

1973-1974 Morecambe

1972-1973 Scarborough FC

1971-1972 Stafford Rangers

1969-1970 Macclesfield Town

1878-1879 Stafford Rangers