| 04 Jun 23 | r01        | Carolina ChaosCarolina Chao | 7 - 8 | Philadelphia WaterdogsPhiladelphia |
| |
| 10 Jun 23 | r02        | Philadelphia WaterdogsPhiladelphia | 9 - 10 | California RedwoodsCalifornia Re |
| |
| 16 Jun 23 | r03        | Philadelphia WaterdogsPhiladelphia | 19 - 18 | New York AtlasNew York Atla |
| |
| 08 Jul 23 | r04        | Philadelphia WaterdogsPhiladelphia | 10 - 7 | Denver OutlawsDenver Outlaw |
| |
| 14 Jul 23 | r05        | Philadelphia WaterdogsPhiladelphia | 16 - 13 | Maryland WhipsnakesMaryland Whip |
| |
| 30 Jul 23 | r07        | Philadelphia WaterdogsPhiladelphia | 18 - 19 | Utah ArchersUtah Archers |
| |
| 06 Aug 23 | r08        | Philadelphia WaterdogsPhiladelphia | 8 - 12 | Boston CannonsBoston Cannon |
| |
| 12 Aug 23 | r09        | New York AtlasNew York Atla | 11 - 14 | Philadelphia WaterdogsPhiladelphia |
| |
| 19 Aug 23 | r10        | Carolina ChaosCarolina Chao | 8 - 13 | Philadelphia WaterdogsPhiladelphia |
| |
| 26 Aug 23 | r11        | Utah ArchersUtah Archers | 13 - 14 | Philadelphia WaterdogsPhiladelphia |
| |
| 04 Sep 23 | QF        | Philadelphia WaterdogsPhiladelphia | 15 - 12 | Maryland WhipsnakesMaryland Whip |
| |
| 10 Sep 23 | SF        | Boston CannonsBoston Cannon | 6 - 17 | Philadelphia WaterdogsPhiladelphia |
| |
| 24 Sep 23 | Final        | Utah ArchersUtah Archers | 15 - 14 | Philadelphia WaterdogsPhiladelphia |