| 28 Oct 23 | r12        | AFC Rushden and DiamondsAFC Rushden a | 1 - 1 | Rugby TownRugby Town |
| 28 Oct 23 | r12        | Anstey NomadsAnstey Nomads | 3 - 0 | Hinckley Leicester RoadHinckley Leic |
| 28 Oct 23 | r12        | Boldmere St MichaelsBoldmere St M | 1 - 1 | Bedworth UnitedBedworth Unit |
| 28 Oct 23 | r12        | Coleshill TownColeshill Tow | 2 - 1 | Cambridge CityCambridge Cit |
| 28 Oct 23 | r12        | Loughborough DynamoLoughborough | 4 - 2 | Gresley RoversGresley Rover |
| 28 Oct 23 | r12        | Lye TownLye Town | 2 - 0 | Spalding UnitedSpalding Unit |
| 28 Oct 23 | r12        | Sporting KhalsaSporting Khal | 0 - 2 | Sutton Coldfield TownSutton Coldfi |
| 21 Nov 23 | r12        | Harborough TownHarborough To | 6 - 1 | Coventry SphinxCoventry Sphi |
| 22 Nov 23 | r12        | Corby TownCorby Town | 2 - 3 | QuornQuorn |
| 23 Jan 24 | r12        | Walsall WoodWalsall Wood | 2 - 1 | Shepshed DynamoShepshed Dyna |