| 15 May 25 | r01        | Erie Sports CenterErie Sports C | 1 - 3 | Cleveland ForceCleveland For |
| |
| 18 May 25 | r02        | FC BuffaloFC Buffalo | 2 - 0 | Erie Sports CenterErie Sports C |
| |
| 24 May 25 | r03        | Erie Sports CenterErie Sports C | 1 - 2 | Steel CitySteel City |
| |
| 31 May 25 | r05        | Erie Sports CenterErie Sports C | 1 - 0 | Akron CityAkron City |
| |
| 07 Jun 25 | r08        | Steel CitySteel City | 4 - 0 | Erie Sports CenterErie Sports C |
| |
| 14 Jun 25 | r10        | Erie Sports CenterErie Sports C | 0 - 1 | FC BuffaloFC Buffalo |
| |
| 15 Jun 25 | r11        | Erie Sports CenterErie Sports C | 1 - 2 | Toledo VillaToledo Villa |
| |
| 21 Jun 25 | r13        | Erie Sports CenterErie Sports C | 0 - 3 | Cleveland ForceCleveland For |
| |
| 28 Jun 25 | r15        | Cleveland ForceCleveland For | 2 - 5 | Erie Sports CenterErie Sports C |
| |
| 29 Jun 25 | r16        | Toledo VillaToledo Villa | 5 - 1 | Erie Sports CenterErie Sports C |
| |
| 05 Jul 25 | r17        | Akron CityAkron City | 2 - 0 | Erie Sports CenterErie Sports C |
| |
| 12 Jul 25 | r19        | FC BuffaloFC Buffalo | 4 - 1 | Erie Sports CenterErie Sports C |