| 21 Sep 23 | r00        | Sioux City MusketeersSioux City Mu | 2 - 3 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 22 Sep 23 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 1 - 3 | Lincoln StarsLincoln Stars |
| 30 Sep 23 | r00        | Madison CapitolsMadison Capit | 7 - 6 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 30 Sep 23 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 4 - 7 | Muskegon LumberjacksMuskegon Lumb |
| 06 Oct 23 | r00        | Youngstown PhantomsYoungstown Ph | 5 - 3 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 07 Oct 23 | r00        | Muskegon LumberjacksMuskegon Lumb | 8 - 2 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 14 Oct 23 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 2 - 5 | Waterloo Black HawksWaterloo Blac |
| 21 Oct 23 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 2 - 3 | Youngstown PhantomsYoungstown Ph |
| 28 Oct 23 | r00        | Sioux City MusketeersSioux City Mu | 6 - 3 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 28 Oct 23 | r00        | Sioux City MusketeersSioux City Mu | 6 - 3 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 04 Nov 23 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 4 - 5 | Green Bay GamblersGreen Bay Gam |
| 05 Nov 23 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 1 - 0 | Green Bay GamblersGreen Bay Gam |
| 11 Nov 23 | r00        | Madison CapitolsMadison Capit | 7 - 9 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 18 Nov 23 | r00        | Cedar Rapids RoughRidersCedar Rapids | 3 - 5 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 19 Nov 23 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 2 - 1 | Youngstown PhantomsYoungstown Ph |
| 19 Nov 23 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 2 - 5 | Youngstown PhantomsYoungstown Ph |
| 25 Nov 23 | r00        | Fargo ForceFargo Force | 8 - 0 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 26 Nov 23 | r00        | Fargo ForceFargo Force | 6 - 0 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 02 Dec 23 | r00        | Madison CapitolsMadison Capit | 6 - 1 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 03 Dec 23 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 4 - 3 | Madison CapitolsMadison Capit |
| 03 Dec 23 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 4 - 3 | USA Hockey National Team USA Hockey Na |
| 09 Dec 23 | r00        | Green Bay GamblersGreen Bay Gam | 5 - 6 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 10 Dec 23 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 2 - 6 | Green Bay GamblersGreen Bay Gam |
| 13 Dec 23 | r00        | USA Hockey National Team USA Hockey Na | 8 - 5 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 16 Dec 23 | r00        | Muskegon LumberjacksMuskegon Lumb | 6 - 2 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 17 Dec 23 | r00        | Muskegon LumberjacksMuskegon Lumb | 4 - 3 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 30 Dec 23 | r00        | Madison CapitolsMadison Capit | 3 - 4 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 31 Dec 23 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 4 - 5 | Madison CapitolsMadison Capit |
| 06 Jan 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 4 - 3 | Sioux Falls StampedeSioux Falls S |
| 07 Jan 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 4 - 5 | Sioux Falls StampedeSioux Falls S |
| 14 Jan 24 | r00        | Waterloo Black HawksWaterloo Blac | 5 - 4 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 14 Jan 24 | r00        | Des Moines BuccaneersDes Moines Bu | 0 - 3 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 20 Jan 24 | r00        | USA Hockey National Team USA Hockey Na | 3 - 4 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 21 Jan 24 | r00        | USA Hockey National Team USA Hockey Na | 5 - 6 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 27 Jan 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 5 - 2 | Cedar Rapids RoughRidersCedar Rapids |
| 28 Jan 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 4 - 2 | Des Moines BuccaneersDes Moines Bu |
| 03 Feb 24 | r00        | Dubuque Fighting SaintsDubuque Fight | 6 - 5 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 04 Feb 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 3 - 5 | Muskegon LumberjacksMuskegon Lumb |
| 04 Feb 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 3 - 2 | Green Bay GamblersGreen Bay Gam |
| 10 Feb 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 4 - 1 | Madison CapitolsMadison Capit |
| 11 Feb 24 | r00        | Cedar Rapids RoughRidersCedar Rapids | 5 - 2 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 17 Feb 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 4 - 5 | Tri-City StormTri-City Stor |
| 18 Feb 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 5 - 3 | Tri-City StormTri-City Stor |
| 18 Feb 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 3 - 1 | Madison CapitolsMadison Capit |
| 24 Feb 24 | r00        | Youngstown PhantomsYoungstown Ph | 2 - 1 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 25 Feb 24 | r00        | Youngstown PhantomsYoungstown Ph | 7 - 1 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 02 Mar 24 | r00        | Green Bay GamblersGreen Bay Gam | 4 - 5 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 03 Mar 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 2 - 6 | Omaha LancersOmaha Lancers |
| 03 Mar 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 6 - 1 | Omaha LancersOmaha Lancers |
| 10 Mar 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 5 - 7 | USA Hockey National Team USA Hockey Na |
| 10 Mar 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 1 - 3 | USA Hockey National Team USA Hockey Na |
| 14 Mar 24 | r00        | Green Bay GamblersGreen Bay Gam | 2 - 4 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 16 Mar 24 | r00        | Lincoln StarsLincoln Stars | 1 - 6 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 16 Mar 24 | r00        | Lincoln StarsLincoln Stars | 2 - 3 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 23 Mar 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 5 - 0 | Cedar Rapids RoughRidersCedar Rapids |
| 24 Mar 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 1 - 5 | Dubuque Fighting SaintsDubuque Fight |
| 30 Mar 24 | r00        | Green Bay GamblersGreen Bay Gam | 5 - 4 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 30 Mar 24 | r00        | Green Bay GamblersGreen Bay Gam | 4 - 5 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 06 Apr 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 4 - 3 | Dubuque Fighting SaintsDubuque Fight |
| 07 Apr 24 | r00        | Dubuque Fighting SaintsDubuque Fight | 4 - 2 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 13 Apr 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 3 - 7 | Muskegon LumberjacksMuskegon Lumb |
| 13 Apr 24 | r00        | Chicago SteelChicago Steel | 1 - 4 | Muskegon LumberjacksMuskegon Lumb |
| 16 Apr 24 | r00        | Green Bay GamblersGreen Bay Gam | 6 - 5 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 17 Apr 24 | r00        | Green Bay GamblersGreen Bay Gam | 2 - 5 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |
| 18 Apr 24 | r00        | Green Bay GamblersGreen Bay Gam | 3 - 2 | Chicago SteelChicago Steel |