| 02 Dec 23 | r22        | Brackley TownBrackley Town | 2 - 1 | Boston United FCBoston United |
| 02 Dec 23 | r22        | HerefordHereford | 1 - 5 | ScunthorpeScunthorpe |
| 02 Dec 23 | r22        | Rushall OlympicRushall Olymp | 1 - 3 | Blyth SpartansBlyth Spartan |
| 12 Dec 23 | r22        | ChorleyChorley | 3 - 2 | Buxton F.C.Buxton F.C. |
| 12 Dec 23 | r22        | Kings Lynn TownKings Lynn To | 1 - 2 | BanburyBanbury |
| 09 Jan 24 | r22        | Bishops StortfordBishops Stort | 2 - 3 | South ShieldsSouth Shields |
| 09 Jan 24 | r22        | SouthportSouthport | 2 - 0 | Darlington F.C.Darlington F. |
| 09 Jan 24 | r22        | Spennymoor Town FCSpennymoor To | 1 - 1 | Scarborough AthleticScarborough A |
| 09 Jan 24 | r22        | Warrington TownWarrington To | 0 - 3 | TamworthTamworth |
| 13 Jan 24 | r22        | Chester CityChester City | 3 - 0 | Gloucester CityGloucester Ci |
| 06 Feb 24 | r22        | CurzonCurzon | 2 - 1 | Alfreton TownAlfreton Town |
| 09 Apr 24 | r22        | Peterborough SportsPeterborough | 1 - 0 | Farsley CelticFarsley Celti |