| 09 Nov 24 | r00        | DrexelDrexel | 73 - 56 | ColgateColgate |
| 13 Nov 24 | r00        | SyracuseSyracuse | 74 - 72 | ColgateColgate |
| 19 Nov 24 | r00        | North Carolina StateNorth Carolin | 72 - 49 | ColgateColgate |
| 23 Nov 24 | r00        | HarvardHarvard | 78 - 67 | ColgateColgate |
| 28 Nov 24 | r00        | UNC WilmingtonUNC Wilmingto | 59 - 72 | ColgateColgate |
| 29 Nov 24 | r00        | Appalachian StateAppalachian S | 72 - 50 | ColgateColgate |
| 30 Nov 24 | r00        | Sam Houston StateSam Houston S | 82 - 78 | ColgateColgate |
| 05 Dec 24 | r00        | ColgateColgate | 57 - 84 | CornellCornell |
| 08 Dec 24 | r00        | NortheasternNortheastern | 78 - 75 | ColgateColgate |
| 12 Dec 24 | r00        | KentuckyKentucky | 78 - 67 | ColgateColgate |
| 15 Dec 24 | r00        | ColgateColgate | 65 - 60 | VermontVermont |
| 22 Dec 24 | r00        | ColgateColgate | 73 - 79 | IonaIona |
| 03 Jan 25 | r00        | ColgateColgate | 71 - 59 | ArmyArmy |
| 05 Jan 25 | r00        | BucknellBucknell | 66 - 60 | ColgateColgate |
| 09 Jan 25 | r00        | ColgateColgate | 67 - 62 | LehighLehigh |
| 11 Jan 25 | r00        | ColgateColgate | 87 - 50 | Boston UniversityBoston Univer |
| 16 Jan 25 | r00        | NavyNavy | 66 - 73 | ColgateColgate |
| 18 Jan 25 | r00        | LafayetteLafayette | 67 - 90 | ColgateColgate |
| 21 Jan 25 | r00        | ColgateColgate | 87 - 80 | BucknellBucknell |
| 25 Jan 25 | r00        | AmericanAmerican | 81 - 77 | ColgateColgate |
| 29 Jan 25 | r00        | ArmyArmy | 84 - 72 | ColgateColgate |
| 01 Feb 25 | r00        | ColgateColgate | 61 - 76 | LafayetteLafayette |
| 03 Feb 25 | r00        | LehighLehigh | 94 - 68 | ColgateColgate |
| 08 Feb 25 | r00        | ColgateColgate | 82 - 68 | Loyola-MarylandLoyola-Maryla |
| 12 Feb 25 | r00        | Holy CrossHoly Cross | 65 - 87 | ColgateColgate |
| 15 Feb 25 | r00        | Boston UniversityBoston Univer | 93 - 91 | ColgateColgate |
| 20 Feb 25 | r00        | ColgateColgate | 79 - 75 | NavyNavy |
| 23 Feb 25 | r00        | Loyola-MarylandLoyola-Maryla | 84 - 65 | ColgateColgate |
| 27 Feb 25 | r00        | ColgateColgate | 81 - 73 | Holy CrossHoly Cross |
| 01 Mar 25 | r00        | ColgateColgate | 59 - 67 | AmericanAmerican |
| 07 Mar 25 | r00        | ColgateColgate | 84 - 55 | ArmyArmy |
| 09 Mar 25 | r00        | AmericanAmerican | 72 - 62 | ColgateColgate |