| 07 Nov 23 | r00        | Sacred HeartSacred Heart | 95 - 51 | BronxvilleBronxville |
| 11 Nov 23 | r00        | IonaIona | 88 - 81 | Sacred HeartSacred Heart |
| 15 Nov 23 | r00        | Holy CrossHoly Cross | 77 - 84 | Sacred HeartSacred Heart |
| 17 Nov 23 | r00        | UMBCUMBC | 85 - 80 | Sacred HeartSacred Heart |
| 18 Nov 23 | r00        | Sacred HeartSacred Heart | 66 - 51 | Loyola-MarylandLoyola-Maryla |
| 21 Nov 23 | r00        | Sacred HeartSacred Heart | 89 - 75 | BinghamtonBinghamton |
| 26 Nov 23 | r00        | Saint JosephsSaint Josephs | 64 - 55 | Sacred HeartSacred Heart |
| 01 Dec 23 | r00        | Sacred HeartSacred Heart | 84 - 90 | New HampshireNew Hampshire |
| 02 Dec 23 | r00        | Sacred HeartSacred Heart | 49 - 70 | Boston UniversityBoston Univer |
| 07 Dec 23 | r00        | St JohnsSt Johns | 85 - 50 | Sacred HeartSacred Heart |
| 09 Dec 23 | r00        | Sacred HeartSacred Heart | 57 - 67 | FairfieldFairfield |
| 16 Dec 23 | r00        | ProvidenceProvidence | 78 - 64 | Sacred HeartSacred Heart |
| 20 Dec 23 | r00        | AlbanyAlbany | 93 - 79 | Sacred HeartSacred Heart |
| 21 Dec 23 | r00        | Sacred HeartSacred Heart | 67 - 57 | DartmouthDartmouth |
| 04 Jan 24 | r00        | Sacred HeartSacred Heart | 79 - 67 | St Francis-PennsylvaniaSt Francis-Pe |
| 21 Jan 24 | r00        | Sacred HeartSacred Heart | 66 - 61 | WagnerWagner |
| 26 Jan 24 | r00        | St Francis-PennsylvaniaSt Francis-Pe | 75 - 71 | Sacred HeartSacred Heart |
| 27 Jan 24 | r00        | Fairleigh DickinsonFairleigh Dic | 93 - 91 | Sacred HeartSacred Heart |
| 02 Feb 24 | r00        | Sacred HeartSacred Heart | 77 - 72 | StonehillStonehill |
| 09 Feb 24 | r00        | Central Connecticut StateCentral Conne | 77 - 70 | Sacred HeartSacred Heart |
| 17 Feb 24 | r00        | WagnerWagner | 53 - 63 | Sacred HeartSacred Heart |
| 23 Feb 24 | r00        | Sacred HeartSacred Heart | 99 - 91 | Fairleigh DickinsonFairleigh Dic |
| 24 Feb 24 | r00        | Sacred HeartSacred Heart | 67 - 68 | Central Connecticut StateCentral Conne |
| 01 Mar 24 | r00        | StonehillStonehill | 51 - 79 | Sacred HeartSacred Heart |
| 07 Mar 24 | r00        | Sacred HeartSacred Heart | 57 - 60 | WagnerWagner |