| 08 Nov 23 | r00        | MarylandMaryland | 68 - 53 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 11 Nov 23 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | 74 - 60 | Coppin StateCoppin State |
| 14 Nov 23 | r00        | FairfieldFairfield | 92 - 45 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 18 Nov 23 | r00        | Georgetown UniversityGeorgetown Un | 83 - 72 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 22 Nov 23 | r00        | AmericanAmerican | 68 - 65 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 25 Nov 23 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | 83 - 87 | HowardHoward |
| 25 Nov 23 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | - | HowardHoward |
| 02 Dec 23 | r00        | ManhattanManhattan | 75 - 74 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 03 Dec 23 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | 80 - 48 | SienaSiena |
| 06 Dec 23 | r00        | MississippiMississippi | 77 - 68 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 09 Dec 23 | r00        | Loyola-MarylandLoyola-Maryla | 64 - 77 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 16 Dec 23 | r00        | St Francis-PennsylvaniaSt Francis-Pe | 65 - 72 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 21 Dec 23 | r00        | GeorgiaGeorgia | 94 - 82 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 30 Dec 23 | r00        | Delaware StateDelaware Stat | 77 - 73 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 06 Jan 24 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | 74 - 69 | CanisiusCanisius |
| 07 Jan 24 | r00        | Saint PetersSaint Peters | 70 - 64 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 14 Jan 24 | r00        | IonaIona | 87 - 70 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 20 Jan 24 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | 65 - 48 | MaristMarist |
| 21 Jan 24 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | 71 - 82 | NiagaraNiagara |
| 26 Jan 24 | r00        | QuinnipiacQuinnipiac | 79 - 65 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 27 Jan 24 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | 62 - 66 | RiderRider |
| 03 Feb 24 | r00        | MaristMarist | 58 - 76 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 04 Feb 24 | r00        | SienaSiena | 61 - 68 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 09 Feb 24 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | 82 - 78 | ManhattanManhattan |
| 10 Feb 24 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | 96 - 79 | QuinnipiacQuinnipiac |
| 17 Feb 24 | r00        | RiderRider | 61 - 57 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 18 Feb 24 | r00        | FairfieldFairfield | 94 - 80 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 24 Feb 24 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | 65 - 70 | Saint PetersSaint Peters |
| 25 Feb 24 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | 72 - 65 | IonaIona |
| 02 Mar 24 | r00        | CanisiusCanisius | 61 - 56 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 03 Mar 24 | r00        | NiagaraNiagara | 72 - 91 | Mount St MarysMount St Mary |
| 09 Mar 24 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | 92 - 96 | FairfieldFairfield |
| 12 Mar 24 | r00        | Mount St MarysMount St Mary | 61 - 77 | CanisiusCanisius |