| 25 Aug 23 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 4 - 1 | StockportStockport |
| 27 Aug 23 | r00        | OldhamOldham | 2 - 0 | DerbyDerby |
| 01 Sep 23 | r00        | StockportStockport | 0 - 0 | DerbyDerby |
| 03 Sep 23 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 2 - 1 | OldhamOldham |
| 08 Sep 23 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 1 - 0 | Leyton OrientLeyton Orient |
| 15 Sep 23 | r00        | Leyton OrientLeyton Orient | 2 - 0 | DerbyDerby |
| 22 Sep 23 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 2 - 3 | Bristol CityBristol City |
| 29 Sep 23 | r00        | Bristol CityBristol City | 0 - 8 | DerbyDerby |
| 06 Oct 23 | r00        | HullHull | 0 - 1 | DerbyDerby |
| 13 Oct 23 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 4 - 1 | HullHull |
| 20 Oct 23 | r00        | SouthamptonSouthampton | 0 - 0 | DerbyDerby |
| 27 Oct 23 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 1 - 0 | SouthamptonSouthampton |
| 03 Nov 23 | r00        | StokeStoke | 1 - 1 | DerbyDerby |
| 10 Nov 23 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 1 - 1 | StokeStoke |
| 17 Nov 23 | r00        | FulhamFulham | 3 - 2 | DerbyDerby |
| 24 Nov 23 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 3 - 3 | FulhamFulham |
| 01 Dec 23 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 5 - 0 | Crystal PalaceCrystal Palac |
| 08 Dec 23 | r00        | Crystal PalaceCrystal Palac | 0 - 1 | DerbyDerby |
| 15 Dec 23 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 2 - 0 | BlackpoolBlackpool |
| 22 Dec 23 | r00        | BlackpoolBlackpool | 4 - 0 | DerbyDerby |
| 25 Dec 23 | r00        | Nelson FCNelson FC | 2 - 1 | DerbyDerby |
| 26 Dec 23 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 6 - 0 | Nelson FCNelson FC |
| 29 Dec 23 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 1 - 1 | Sheffield WedsSheffield Wed |
| 05 Jan 24 | r00        | Sheffield WedsSheffield Wed | 1 - 0 | DerbyDerby |
| 19 Jan 24 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 6 - 1 | South ShieldsSouth Shields |
| 26 Jan 24 | r00        | South ShieldsSouth Shields | 3 - 2 | DerbyDerby |
| 09 Feb 24 | r00        | BuryBury | 1 - 0 | DerbyDerby |
| 16 Feb 24 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 3 - 0 | Manchester UnitedManchester Un |
| 23 Feb 24 | r00        | Manchester UnitedManchester Un | 0 - 0 | DerbyDerby |
| 27 Feb 24 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 0 - 2 | BuryBury |
| 01 Mar 24 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 2 - 1 | BarnsleyBarnsley |
| 08 Mar 24 | r00        | BarnsleyBarnsley | 1 - 3 | DerbyDerby |
| 15 Mar 24 | r00        | BradfordBradford | 1 - 2 | DerbyDerby |
| 22 Mar 24 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 0 - 0 | BradfordBradford |
| 29 Mar 24 | r00        | Port ValePort Vale | 2 - 0 | DerbyDerby |
| 05 Apr 24 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 2 - 0 | Port ValePort Vale |
| 12 Apr 24 | r00        | LeedsLeeds | 1 - 1 | DerbyDerby |
| 19 Apr 24 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 2 - 0 | LeedsLeeds |
| 21 Apr 24 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 1 - 0 | CoventryCoventry |
| 22 Apr 24 | r00        | CoventryCoventry | 0 - 1 | DerbyDerby |
| 26 Apr 24 | r00        | LeicesterLeicester | 3 - 0 | DerbyDerby |
| 03 May 24 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 4 - 0 | LeicesterLeicester |