| 04 Sep 09 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 2 - 2 | OldhamOldham |
| 11 Sep 09 | r00        | BarnsleyBarnsley | 5 - 1 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 13 Sep 09 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 2 - 2 | Glossop North End AFCGlossop North |
| 18 Sep 09 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 1 - 1 | FulhamFulham |
| 25 Sep 09 | r00        | BurnleyBurnley | 2 - 0 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 02 Oct 09 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 1 - 2 | Leeds City FCLeeds City FC |
| 09 Oct 09 | r00        | WolvesWolves | 4 - 2 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 16 Oct 09 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 5 - 0 | GainsboroughGainsborough |
| 23 Oct 09 | r00        | GrimsbyGrimsby | 0 - 2 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 30 Oct 09 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 1 - 1 | Manchester CityManchester Ci |
| 06 Nov 09 | r00        | LeicesterLeicester | 3 - 1 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 13 Nov 09 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 1 - 0 | LincolnLincoln |
| 20 Nov 09 | r00        | Leyton OrientLeyton Orient | 3 - 0 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 27 Nov 09 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 1 - 2 | BlackpoolBlackpool |
| 04 Dec 09 | r00        | HullHull | 7 - 0 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 11 Dec 09 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 1 - 3 | DerbyDerby |
| 18 Dec 09 | r00        | StockportStockport | 1 - 1 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 25 Dec 09 | r00        | Glossop North End AFCGlossop North | 4 - 1 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 27 Dec 09 | r00        | West BromWest Brom | 3 - 1 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 28 Dec 09 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 0 - 1 | Bradford Park AvenueBradford Park |
| 01 Jan 10 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 0 - 1 | West BromWest Brom |
| 08 Jan 10 | r00        | OldhamOldham | 1 - 1 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 22 Jan 10 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 2 - 1 | BarnsleyBarnsley |
| 29 Jan 10 | r00        | FulhamFulham | 0 - 0 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 12 Feb 10 | r00        | Leeds City FCLeeds City FC | 2 - 1 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 19 Feb 10 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 1 - 0 | WolvesWolves |
| 26 Feb 10 | r00        | GainsboroughGainsborough | 1 - 0 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 28 Feb 10 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 2 - 1 | BurnleyBurnley |
| 05 Mar 10 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 2 - 4 | GrimsbyGrimsby |
| 12 Mar 10 | r00        | Manchester CityManchester Ci | 3 - 0 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 19 Mar 10 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 2 - 1 | LeicesterLeicester |
| 26 Mar 10 | r00        | LincolnLincoln | 3 - 2 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 28 Mar 10 | r00        | Bradford Park AvenueBradford Park | 5 - 0 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 02 Apr 10 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 1 - 2 | Leyton OrientLeyton Orient |
| 09 Apr 10 | r00        | BlackpoolBlackpool | 2 - 0 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 16 Apr 10 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 0 - 2 | HullHull |
| 23 Apr 10 | r00        | DerbyDerby | 3 - 1 | BirminghamBirmingham |
| 30 Apr 10 | r00        | BirminghamBirmingham | 3 - 0 | StockportStockport |